Simran Kaur's profileSimran's SpacePhotosBlogListsMore Tools Help

Blog


    November 06

    Golden autumn in Kabul

     

    Autumn, glorious autumn ! The temperatures are gorgeous, the skies are blue, leaves are falling, the last insects are squirreling around and the last rose paddles are dropping away.

    After a long time I find the time to truly relax.

    The past few weeks and months had a lot of tension in them: first and foremost the elections which for us had up-kept the hope of true change in the leadership of this country. My boyfriend was part of the campaign and often worked long hours. Now it has all come to nothing because of a principle-based decision which lead into a dead end. If it had been me I would have just gone along with the 2nd round and if there are again fraud allegations I would have had another investigation rolled out. But Dr. Abdullah decided otherwise. He is taking the long way around – let’s hope it has the desired outcome soon.

    Then my boyfriend and I fell out at one point – he accusing me of indiscretions – his full tendency to jealousy surfacing. But we worked it out, we got back together. But the stress I went through is indescribable, particularly because his allegations were totally baseless.

    Then we had this major attack on a UN guesthouse – I woke up from the shooting and explosions nearby my house. It was a surreal experience. There is no direct impact and yet one follows the events on TV while it’s happening right around the corner. 8 people died in my neighbourhood and I watched Al Jazeera !

    Then – two weeks ago – I moved into a new house after my previous landlord decided to cancel the contract which I had signed with her representatives 6 months prior.for 2 years. When Madam herself then returned from the US she decided that all this wasn’t what she wanted. Ah well, I didn’t wait for any BS to surface and simply moved out. Luckily I found this great house not far from my old one in Shar-e-Now. Enough space for me, my office, another company’s office and two more rooms to rent out in a separate attached apartment.

    Today I’m sitting in beautiful Flower Street Cafe enjoying this beautiful Juma.

    I have been wanting to go to Panjshir for the longest time. But somehow always something came up. . Now I must go soon – I miss going there, going to Amir Sahib’s tomb. Maybe next week …

    In the meantime our Library project has also stalled because of everybody’s involvement with the campaign. But I managed to finalise the website and a couple of other things. But now we need to get kicking – by his 10-years anniversary this institution should be established and running in at least one or two cities. (yes, I haven’t given up hope. How can I – he was the reason why I came here, so if I achieve nothing else but to build a memorial in his honour I have fulfilled my purpose ….)

    November 04

    Karzai’s “victory” – or “keeping the peace”

     

    What just happened?

    Did they just make a fraudster the new President of Afghanistan? And it was so swift that it made everybody’s head spin (they can be fast in this country if they want to).

    They made someone President whose vote in the first round was 80% rigged* and thus does not enjoy any legitimacy to be in this position.

    But nobody of the international community even blinked !! No doubts, no questions – simply pure acceptance hidden behind Ban Ki Moons cheesy diplomatic smile.

    Why? Because no one is actually interested in up keeping due process or instilling honest legitimacy which is the underpinning of a strong government – all they are interested in is keeping the country quiet – and that at almost any cost, it seems. Quiet, for the moment, so that they – in their misguided strategies for this country – don’t have more headaches on their hands.

    It was the same during the Taliban years – no one really moved to get rid of that regime which suppressed the country because they were the only ones who were able to keep it “quiet”. Western countries made an indirect pact with these forces simply with the goal not to miss out on any mineral wealth and strategic advantages which arise from a good relationship with Afghanistan – regardless of their rulers.

    There may be large parts of the population who will be less than happy about that. And even if it doesn’t come to widespread demonstrations the legitimacy of the new President will be questioned at every occasion, as will the quality of democracy in general and local power holders will deduce new opportunities for themselves. This will contribute to further disintegration of the country: in the south and south-east the Taliban is gaining strength, and in the north Abdullah supporters who feel cheated may try to “do their own thing”. Overall not helpful !!

    What should have been done instead is this:

    A interim President should have been put in place until such time that there is enough time to hold 2nd round elections and remove all tainted people from the process. That way the new president would have gained an honest vote and legitimacy among the people.

    But that of course would have given the internationals more uncertainty for a prolonged period of time – this was unacceptable, so they went with the fowl solution – in the name of “keeping the country quiet”

     

    * numbers given by the opposition observers during the recent re-counting of the first-round votes. 30% was the official number later released so as to avoid potential violence and other trouble, I suppose; still and already Karzai was pushed below 50%.

    September 12

    If they have an ounce of integrity left …

    • They will not allow this ridiculous vote rigging to be successful
    • They will put Karzai into his place and subject him to the electoral law – to any law for that matter.
    • They will not let someone who has no respect for anyone but himself and his bought cronies to play with everyone else
    • They will not allow to let Afghanistan slide ever deeper into a crisis
    • They will rescue the democratic process so as to give at least a bit of weight to the hollow institutions they installed
    • They will rescue themselves

    With “They” I mean the international community who has imposed their ways onto this country without much consideration of the circumstance they were meddling with. “They” are the ones who now have to take a stance and not become a culprit in this unprecedented, shameless and in-your-face election fraud.

    If they have an ounce of integrity left – that is what they do. But do they?

    September 10

    8 years on – Ahmad Shah Massoud’s spirit is needed more than ever

    An anniversary tribute of a different nature

    Kojah Bahoudin 2000 1

    I recently met a French diplomat who felt to comment on Amir Sahib in a pseudo-intellectual manner as follows: “He should continue to be an example for Afghans; he developed from an ignorant village boy into an influential personality”.

    ??? – I was proud of myself at that moment that I did not engage him in a fundamental argument over who Massoud actually was. But it made me realise once more where the problem lies when it comes to this great leader: as often with such personalities who did not think themselves important enough he did not write books of his ideas and ideals, he did not even appoint a successor as he hoped his struggle to be a temporary one and his leadership to be replaced within his lifetime by a democratically elected government of the whole of Afghanistan.

    And now we have ended up with the situation in which only those who worked and lived with him still remember his true personality, his open and great mind and intellect, while all those who didn’t have this fortune put him into a drawer of their liking. And the spectrum is wide:

    Some will put him in the drawer of “warlord who destroyed Kabul”, others into the drawer “our hero who ended the cold war”.

    Very few nowadays still understand the great intellectual depth and humanity which he incorporated, the physical and mental strain he was in for more than 20 years, the political pulls and pushes he had to balance. But most of all most do not understand anymore his intentions for the whole of Afghanistan – far from being a ethnically motivated warlord. For example he used to say that ‘dividing Afghanistan into ethnic groups is as much of a sin as saying there is more than one God’. True - he himself adjusted his political goal posts and aspirations over the 25 years of his struggle, but always with Afghanistan as a whole at heart and never with narrow ideological or religious focus – whether in is younger or older days.

    Already in his early school years in Kabul the teachers attested him with very high intelligence, he never coerced people into following his pious heart.Much rather people and his peers followed him in a very natural manner from youth onward.

    So to call him a narrow-minded village boy who set out to defend his little fiefdom or to put him posthumously into any drawer does not do justice to this great mind and demonstrate clearly again that his legacy is at danger of being lost in the fading memory of people, in the abuse of his name for some people’s limited motives.

    His values - more necessary in Afghanistan than ever before

    Contrasting this we should recall now more than ever what he had in mind for Afghanistan and what he was denied realising.

    • He envisioned a truly democratic country, the structures of which had to reflect the culture of the country and its inner workings.
    • He advocated federalist structures so as to reflect the regional differences and diversity of Afghanistan and thereby still be able to integrate the country.
    • He advocated a moderate Islam to govern Afghanistan but without suppressing other religious minorities or other trains of thought for that matter. Towards the end of his life he even tended towards advocating more secular structures as he had realised that religion in government could also lead to much strive.
    • He advocated equal rights for men and women, he encouraged female education and their ability to pursue a carrier outside the home but in public life just like men.
    • Generally he was a strong supporter of education as he himself furthered his knowledge throughout his life – whether it was the arts or the sciences. He incorporated talent for both and he tried to instill the thirst for knowledge in both his children and his followers.
    • he advocated independence from outside forces. And while he always sought the cooperation of foreign countries in his struggles he always sought the political independence and neutrality of Afghanistan.

    All the above now seem to become an alternative to the way things have been handled so far in Afghan politics. With the failure of the current political rulers clearly before us we need to re-think the political and government concepts with which we are approaching the revival and development of this country.

    We need to design structures which reflect the current development and education level of this country so as to strengthen governance and rule of law. The moderates in society and politics need to be supported and radicals cut down with decisive force. Massoud should not have died in vain while fighting those evils which are no threatening to engulf this country again. He was a shining light in the darkness spread by these ideologies – and this light must brighten up the whole of Afghanistan – if necessary with strong handed support. But this strong hand is only just that – a support – a support which assists good governance and rule of law. But by itself the strong hand is nothing.

    An attempt to preserve his memory

    With this in mind we need to preserve for future generations who Amir Sahib was at heart. For this purpose please donate generously to the Ahmad Shah Massoud Library Association. We want to build a Library Centre in each large Afghan city in Massoud’s honour, with the purpose to carry forward his “heart” and his beautiful mind – his democratic values, his cultural appreciation, his views on women’s rights and his educational emphasis.

    Our plans, funding and contact details can be reviewed at: www.massoudlibrary.org  We are an Afghan-international effort in the honour of Ahmad Shah Massoud.

    August 05

    Thoughts in an airport

    What is it with this country - despite all its nonsense - when I  am leaving there is regret in my heart - and if it's only for 10 days.

    Singapore has been my home for many years and everything there will be familiar. But now I live here in a country most foreigners living here will never understand. All those details so unique to this part of the world have become familiar and at times I am even finding explanations for them.

    Still it seems all modernity that is present here has been forced upon it. Somehow this country is not ready for it.

    Like this airport I'm sitting in. It is leaps of progress away from the airport I first landed in in September 2005. Then the wires were hanging off a ceiling which had not seen an attempt to repair it for decades. Now this airport has become the domestic terminal and a new international terminal has been built. And yet - out of three customs counters only one is open, the air conditioners are not switched on, there are no loudspeakers to announce the flights and the toilets are squad toilets (!).

    There is no indulgence of convenience - and the faces match this.

    It is a strange society with a tremendously strong tap on progress - many young ones want to escape this - but can they cope with what the West will force them to adjust to? Still societal changes are on the surface at best - and only in Kabul - and mostly only because there is financial  pressure from donors. Very few men for example want to see real female liberation, everything else is lip service. Many nowadays advocate girls' education - but  how many husbands will let their wives work? 

    So why not stay in Singapore? What keeps me here? Cynics - like my mother - will quickly jump to the conclusion that it's only a guy who keeps me here. Well of sorts that's not wrong - but there are wider reasons why he keeps me here: we share a dream, the dream to realise another man's dream. We are hoping now that Dr. Abduallah can win the elections, because he is the only choice that is even remotely related to Amir Sahib, to his dreams, to his ideals. We want to build his memorial ... it sounds not much to be working for as the tide swells against us, but for us that's most there is.

    May 30

    An “exhibition” in Panjshir

    What can you say? It was old everything and repeat everything and all about Reza. No one could make out what was the purpose of it all, there were no captions on the photos.

    Several weeks ago Reza asked me “to do the publicity” for this exhibit which he had promised to Amir Sahib many years ago. Further we could do fundraising for both Parvaz and the Library at that occasion.

    Well, in true Reza fashion, nothing came out of it of course – no fundraising – at least not for the Library – and certainly no involvement of my unimportant self. I was not even briefed of the inauguration event taking place on Friday 21st May. When I got there at about 13.00 all the chairs were being cleared away.

    Hey – another lesson, and a final tick off my list.

    April 05

    Requests to the new Afghan President - rule of law

    Another important factor to stabilise Afghanistan is the effective establishment of the rule of law.


    Currently the legal situation of Afghanistan is most dissatisfying and contributes to the weakness of the central government. The absence of a nationwide enforceable legal code and the corrupt and inefficient state of the nation's court system has withdrawn wide areas of society from the influence of the government and justice needs are filled out by ad-hoc mechanisms instead.

    An enforceable (for both citizens as well as law enforcement agencies) legal code penetrating nation-wide all areas of life, however, is vital in order  to ensure the stability of the government and its institutions as well as ensure a secure environment for doing business which in itself again is an important development sector.

    As a result the area of law enforcement needs to be strengthened significantly. Here, too, the issues needs to be tackled from different angles:

    1. Law  enforcement agencies need to be put into the position to effectively implement the law
    2. Citizens must be put into the position to enforce their rights
    3. Effective law-making
    4. civic education campaigns linked to a system of reinforcing sanctions

     

    1.

    Due to the absence of a functioning civil society since and even before the conflicts the current generations of Afghans have not been trained in the application of laws and the necessity of their application. This mind-set reaches into the smallest areas of life where many people try to circumvent rules and regulations which are mostly seen as negotiable in some form or the other.

    It is therefore important to train and guide the population in their civic duties and legal obligations. Respect before the law and its implementing bodies need to be nurtured. The mind-set of "exceptions" needs to be removed and a strict application of the law to all - regardless of creed and name - must be followed.

    To this end it is vital for the police force and other law-enforcement bodies charged with this implementation to be integrated very strongly in the civil services reform suggested in my previous blog entry so that their work is carried out in an incorruptible manner.

    2.

    If, however, the rule of law is propagated from the side of the state it must also offer the opportunity for citizens to enforce their rights.

    While the enforcement mechanisms and underpinning legal codes may vary based on the issues at hand - the path towards dispute resolution has to be clearly regulated and must apply to all equally. Access must be affordable and procedures transparent and for all concerned to follow. There must be financial support for the underprivileged so that they may access the correct dispute resolution path prescribed by the law and do not have to rely on doubtful, illegal courses of justice.

    Resolution settlement must be based on the laws applying to the area at hand and judges or other facilitators must be trained professionals.

    Here again the courts and alternative dispute resolution mechanisms must be part of the civil services reform and its strict code.

    The legal  profession needs to be promoted and expanded

    3.

    Rule of law begins with the conception of laws and the law-making process in parliament. The current Afghan parliament is inefficient in concluding the legal process of law-making within reasonable time frames. This has largely to do with the absence of stable majorities in parlieament and the fact that the opinion forming process is a swaggering one. In order to streamline the law-making capabiltiy of the parliament the following reforms should be carried out:

    • Introduction of political parties: political parties take the opinion-forming process out of parliament and into pre-decision party forums. This results in established opinions once the decisons are put before parliament. Political parties also make for clearer majorities.
    • change in electorial system: currently there are no established majorities in parliament. This is also caused by the electoral system which attempts to follow the prinicple "one man one vote" but makes for a fractured parliament with weak decison power. If changed to a majority voting system no more than three parties will be permanently esetablished in parliament. Voters should vote for party lists in constituencies and only the list with the simple majority in a constituency makes it to parliament while all others are obmitted.
    • remove the presidential sytem: it is to be replaced with a parliamentary system which votes for a Prime Minister. This Prime Minster is supported by the majority in parliament. That way executive and parliament majority will mostly be in sync and decisions are taken more swiftly.

    With the above measures confidence in the parliament will be raised and faith in the overall system of governance among the people strengthend.

     

    4.

    A society in which the largest portion of the populace is uneducated, guidance in civic behaviour is necessary. One example is road traffic:

    Once the police has been reformed and strengthened in its law enforcement position, traffic rules have to be propagated through the media, local training centres and other means and strictly enforced by the traffic police with an equally strict application of a fair but tough fine system. If the police remains corrupt everybody can bribe their way around the application of the traffic rules.

    Similarly other social behaviour, such as littering, can be tackled that way, too.

    At the same time the public must be educated of their rights which they must be in the position to enforce

    Civic society campaigns also should extend into educating the public about the political system, its purpose, its reasons, the people's role in it and their rights and duties.

    Requests to the new Afghan President - eradication of corruption

    Corruption is the fundamental evil which stands in the way of a reliable and effective governance in the name of the people. Instead it has become an executive often working for its own benefit only. As a result the people do not experience this government as beneficial and support for it is withdrawn. Lacking a viable alternative the shortcomings created by such an inefficient government are filled by undesirable, backward-looking but solution-promising forces like the Talilban.

    A corruption free government and civil service is also an essential precursor for the implementation of the rule of law which is otherwise consistently undermined

    It is therefore of fundamental importance that corruption be eradicated.


    A widely corruption-free society starts with the government institutions setting a stellar example of incorruptibility. This is currently not the case:

    The ordinary Afghan experiences corruption at  most contact points with the civil service and government institutions and employment in it is distributed by criteria of nepotism rather than meritocracy.

    Over twenty years of lawless existence have instilled a mind-set of shortsighted advantage-taking in Afghan society and the absence of an effective rule of law compounds this. I am concerning myself with the latter in another blog entry.

    Due to this engrained thinking it is vital to tackle the problem from two angles:

    1.        engaging those who ask for and take bribes

    2.        engaging those who are forced to pay bribes and who thereby fuel the system

     

     

    1. This step requires radical civil service reform and a mighty heart to see it through.

    A civil service reform requires:

    • Streamlining of all government and civil service organizations. Streamlining is required to ensure efficient work processes and yet ensure enough division of labour and responsibilities so as to minimise direct contact with the public which means minimising corruption opportunities. This streamlining needs to be visible and swift
    • Re-training and re-education of the civil servants. - This needs to accompany the streamlining exercise. It is likely  to succeed best with younger personnel. A major retrenchment exercise is therefore necessary to both eliminate excess workforce as well inflexible minds. In order to avoid social hardship this measure needs to be accompanied by a sufficiently stocked pension fund which may have to run for no less than 20 years. The donor communmity should be address for funding this pension program.
    • Increment of civil servant salaries and introduction of fringe benefits. - A lean civil service will allow the salaries, pensions and other fringe benefits of the remaining staff to be raised significantly and will eliminate a major cause for corruption: an insufficient livelihood. Subsequent increments and additional benefits should be performance-based.
    • Introduction of a strict civil service and anti-corruption code accompanied by an equally strict sanction system, implemented by a reformed special force of the police integrated into a anti-corruption task force. In this regard the government of Singapore should be consulted who has demonstrated with extraordinary success in the 1960 / 70s how to rid a country of corruption.

     

    2. This step tackles the culture of corruption from its other angle. It includes both discouraging offering bribes as well as encouraging legal behaviour.

    In order to achieve that the first must meet the full force of the above suggested anti-corruption law and in order to achieve the second legal behaviour must be actively rewarded.

    The anti-corruption law must not hesitate to punish those who offer bribes together with those who take them; they should be exempted, however, if they assist in uncovering a corruption plot.

    Requests for the new Afghan President

    Post-conflict countries attract the most eclectic bunch of people:

    The tree-huggers, the humanitarians, the economists, the pioneers (those that have no other choice and those who dare to come), the returnees and the carpetbaggers. The latter feed on other peoples misfortunes, treat the poor as servants and slaves, nurture corruption and tend to be trouble makers by and large.

    The carpetbaggers can never be avoided in such post-conflict countries and times. But it must be the goal of any political leadership to eliminate them from influence and make those people's personal attitudes and mind-sets the bar by which they are judged and employed, not their family name or relatives' influence. Unfortunately the current Afghan government has been less than successful at that.

    Contrary to the current administration I would like to call on the upcoming Afghan President to select a team of upright Afghans who do exist - I know some of them personally - and start putting the political and societal framework of this country right.

    Above and beyond that there are a number of essential reform projects which need to be tackled swiftly in order to put this country onto sound foundations. I will be adding a post on each  topic to this space.

    As the reader might notice "security" is not one of them. The reason for this is that if the above can be achieved security will come as the support for the insurgency will drop automatically as they are deprived of oxygen. It is essential for the central government to win the trust of the people - then the Talibs will solve themselves.

    January 26

    Winter Weather in Kabul

     

    Today is a drizzly grey day, with temperatures just above freezing. The town turns into a mud-puddle at such occasions with the unpaved side roads slowly becoming lakes. This winter has not been very cold so far, compared to 2007 and 2006 when temperatures regularly dipped to –20C at night

    For some reason I remembered today the clear skies we had only two days ago and a picture I felt compelled to take.

    It was a clear January morning in Kabul. The sun was just starting to peek over the mountains. I was rushing to get ready to go to the office as I made my way to the kitchen, crossing my roof terrace. But this breathtaking view stopped me in my steps: the snow covered mountains surrounding Kabul were tinged in a light orange-pink hue. Picture perfect winter weather.

    Technorati Tags: ,

    January 22

    How to get rid of the Taliban

     

    It has been proven very difficult to eliminate the insurgency in Afghanistan.

    Large military involvement has failed and political efforts to stem the flow of trained Al-Qaida and Taliban fighters out of Pakistan have not yielded any results either.


    Implementing a political system which installs good governance has failed so far as well because of the shortsighted and culturally tainted decisions made on behalf of Afghanistan by politicians with "cut and paste" solutions.

    If, on the other hand, good governance were to be established in Afghanistan, the largest majority of Afghans would be supporting this government in the name of sustained peace and development. Whether they can make a cross on a piece of paper every four years or not will become at least secondary. So, as a first step, a political system which suits the country's level of development needs to be introduced to curb the influence which the Taliban exercise  over wide parts of the population - especially in the south.

    But with their arrogance and heavily tilted world-view such a regime change will never be entertained much less supported by the foreign powers who pull the strings behind the scenes and thereby will stand in their own way of curing this country's ailments. I have eluded to that in more detail in my previous entry.

    In their desperation the same foreign powers have now been considering for a while to arm local villagers so that those can "defend" themselves against the Taliban. Two issues need to be considered in connection with this:

    • Arming the villagers - even if that were managed by the local shuras - is an admission of the central government's weakness and thus does not exactly support keeping the current regime in power.
    • I refuse to believe the fact that the villagers in the south are actual victims who require assistance to resist the Taliban. I believe that this is a fundamental misconception of those suggesting this "solution". Much rather one should consider the fact that for some strange reason the Taliban has never run into much resistance in the southern Pashtun areas of the country while they found and are finding it much harder to gain ground in the non-Pashtun areas. While this is a politically incorrect question to ask, one needs to pose it: why?

    Do the internationals, who are now suggesting arming the southern villages in defense against the Taliban, really believe that the people there need foreigners to arm them if they really wanted to fight an enemy? I believe not.

    It has been said that re-arming of the villages would result in a resurgence of local uncontrolled militias like in the 1990s with local power holders fighting each other. This, too, I believe is a grave misconception which also assumes that arming themselves is dependant on foreigners or a defunct central government allowing them to.

    By contrast it is hard to believe that whoever wants to arm himself and his following can would have difficulties to do so in Afghanistan. The borders to the neighbouring countries are wide open and any type of weapon suitable for an effective resistance can be smuggled in - with our without the support of the border police.

    What is my point? My point is that if the residents of areas controlled by the Taliban wanted to resist they could resist out of their own efforts. This has been done before - just not in the south. In those days, too, in the first round of a Taliban take-over of Afghanistan, they ran into open doors down south. They could take the south easily, finding no resistance among their Pashtun brothers. And it's the same thing happening today: the bottom line is that the residents of the south are not ready to confront their brothers in language and culture against what they perceive to be a "Kafir" supported, corrupt central government.

    The point is not that we have poor suffering southern villagers begging for grassroots assistance in the fight against the Taliban - there is no resistance to begin with. Much rather are the people sitting on the fence - waiting for who wins the conflict in order to them. And anyway: supporting Muslims is always preferred over supporting Kafirs - even if that means prolonged suffering and poverty.

    And this leads to another misconception among the donor community: if the south is given the majority of the donor support, by i.e. building roads, airports etc the residents will sway their opinion with regards to poppy cultivation and support for the Taliban. I believe, they won't - for the same reason they don't source their own guns to fight the Taliban.

    So, as a result the donor community will not only be ineffective in the south they will also lose support in the rest of the country by withdrawing funds from those areas which have not engaged with the Taliban much or at all. This will make the situation worse as the insurgency will not be able to be confined to certain parts of the country but will spread.

    The conclusion, hence, is that only the building of stable good governance which reaches into all corners of the country can suck oxygen from the Taliban insurgence and eventually suffocate them. And for this we need a different political system which over a generation phases in democratic structures and does not super-impose them on an uneducated populace unable to handle the freedoms which come with it. If the yearning for law and order is not fulfilled by this government there will always be others promising to fill it - and that is why the Taliban is still around - not because of the poppies, not because of their human-right neglecting suppressing rule in areas they control. It's because of the lack of law and order which a people has been suffering from for over 20 years and which it has enough of.

    January 13

    "We are dangerously short of cultivated people" Vivian Westwood recently on Talk Asia, CNN

     

    This I have felt keenly myself for a long time. Is it because of that that Ahmad Shah Massoud has drawn me so much to him? Because he exudes culture and humanity?

    I have somehow always looked for someone I can truly look up to, someone I can lean against, who takes and gives at the same time - without him crumbling, without him building protective barriers. Emotional honesty takes strength. And finding a truly strong man is hard to do - especially if you are a strong woman. There are few people who impress me.

    Cultivated people for whom their outlook is neither narrow nor just skin-deep, who judge this world with humanity and wisdom are indeed in short supply these days. How I wish to be close to someone like this - in order to grow and gather strength.

    Technorati Tags:
    November 28

    Kabul Diaries, late November 2008

    I was lying on my Afghan bed on the roof terrace of our house the other day and as I closed my eyes I noticed the different sounds around me. The late autumn sun was warming my clothes. It was generally quiet, so I could distinguish the more intricate sounds. 

    The generator humming in the back of the house.

    Children chattering in the street.

    A flog of pigeons flying back and forth below the blue sky between the bare Kabul mountains Their wings make a particular sound as they carve the air and there is one bird which must have a ring attached to its legs. It jingles when it passes.

    A kite fluttering overhead. A boy in the street was flying the paper specimen on a long string.

    And then the two-o'clock Azan set in. We have a couple of mosques in the vicinity and they all call at the same time.

    Kabul in sounds - peaceful. If this only can be sustained

    November 07

    Kabul Diaries, October 2008

    The weather has been beautiful, like most years in this continental, high-altitude climate.

    We have moved to a new house as our staff strength is increasing due to the World Bank sponsored industrial park near Jalalabad.

    I moved to the top floor together with my housemate. There we have a big terrace and no praying eyes from male guards or visitors. First I had moved into the ground floor but then the guards were assigned to the next door room which made for little privacy. And my boyfriend felt uncomfortable, too, as the guards and their many daily visitors would watch him like monkeys when he visited.

    It's a nice neighbourhood  and from our top-floor we can observe the whole area and have a view onto the mountains.

    Personally things are fine - even though last week my boyfriend and I had a bad fight over him assuming that I am seeing other men. We made up after three days - but the hurt and panic which besieged me was terrible. My fear to lose him over a misunderstanding took over these three days. In such times you can't think and work - your thoughts about the impending loss are too strong.

    There have been a number of kidnappings and murders in town. - Again I had to delete another phone number. This time it was Jason Bresler's the GM of the DHL office here. He was part of our biking group and had been shot by one of his guards when returning back to the office with his deputy. Both men died later. - One British aid-worker was killed by the Talibs accused of preaching Christianity. - One French aid-worker was abducted the other day for ransom. - A Canadian journalist was also abducted at Lake Qagar. Nothing has been heard of here since. It was said that her fixer was in on the deal.

    These cases throw up the questions whether it is better to have protection or whether it is increasingly those who are supposed to protect you who will turn on you as soon as they have the opportunity.

    I have personally always wondered whether or not the "guards" will not side with attackers just to save their own lives if push comes to shove?

    I am against all these gun-slingers being hired to tell you what you can and can't do. As I have stated in the past - low profile is your best protection. Not to go in local taxis is ludicrous - in all the abduction cases there was none done by a taxi driver.

    Overall security seems to be decreasing - not so much from insurgency side it seems but through lawlessness caused by impunity. And the culprit is this western-supported government which is incapable of removing corruption and implementing the rule of law. The jails should be full by now, but instead most criminals - especially the high-profile ones - bribe themselves out of jail or out of police custody.

    Without wanting to repeat the points of my previous blog entry - I am calling again for a different system for Afghanistan. A liberal, overly democratic approach can not clean up the deep mud which threatens to engulf this country. Only after it has been cleaned up and after the clean stage can be maintained - in about 30 years - can we think of transiting to a full parliamentary democracy where people have a qualified opinion for the benefit of the country - and not only for themselves.

     

    September 28

    Changes to my phonebook

     
    One in and one out
     
    There is something about our phonebook entries - they tell about who we are - a socialite or more of a loner, up or down the social strata, and here they also reveal whether we have Afghan friends or not.
    And they record who is coming and who is going - in any sense of the word.
     
    Recently I had two prominent changes to my phonebook.
     
    The first one was an exit. It was my colleague Abid Akmal who was brutally murdered last months after he had mysteriously disappeared two months prior. It was a personal feud as it turned out, nothing Taliban-related. But someone in my closer circle wound up dead. And I didn't really realise it until I deleted his number from my phone. Some people you delete because they leave the country and you will never hear from them again anyway - but never had I deleted someone's phone number because he had died.
     
    The other change to my phone book was an addition: the personal phone number of the First Vice President of Afghanistan. He had rang me - yes he had - one evening last week to invite me for dinner to his house. The purpose was to discuss land and fundraising issues surrounding the Ahmad Shah Massoud Library & Culture Centre. I was totally perplexed to receive his call and couldn't believe it until I was actually sitting down for dinner with him a few days later.
    It was only three years ago that I learned about Ahmad Shah Massoud, and now due to circumstances I was having dinner with his brother? All this pain and longing had brought me to this stage - this I firmly believe.
    August 26

    Where are we headed?

    Where are we headed?


     

    There is an unease creeping in on us these days. Lots of activity is reported - but none of the good kind:

    The talibs seem to be encroaching in on the capital. There have been more and more attacks on trucks between Kabul and Torkham, Wardak and Logar. Three aid workers have been murdered yesterday in Loghar There have been many rape cases - even of young children - and many kidnapped businessmen, among them one of my Afghan colleagues, snatched under still mysterious circumstances.

     

    Things look menacing these days and have eventually moved into my own backyard. But worst of all no one seems capable of doing anything about it. Yet one doesn't seem to realise it because still things are peaceful, the Fridays are green and blue, spent under the trees of my garden. Biking is still on our mind and we'll go again as soon as it turns cooler.

     

    But when will this bubble burst? Or will someone get their act together shortly before there is open war over the capital?

     

    The problem is two-fold:

     

    The first issue is Pakistan. If Pakistan is not brought in line and their radical elements which feed the Afghan insurgency are eradicated (which means beyond considerations of human rights and other liberties) than this cancer will grow until Afghanistan is again on its knees.

    While here and there we hear voices - especially from US military side - which put full blame on Pakistan for supporting the Afghan insurgency - there is no concrete and uncompromising action taken by Western governments towards the Pak government. The longer we wait the more difficult this will become as more and more Pakistani institutions will get undermined and entangled with radical forces such as the Talibs. This has already happened with part of the army and with - according to expert observers - with at least 50% of the ISI. How, may I ask, will it be possible for the Pakistani government to take the required stringent action against the frontier areas if large portions of those institutions which ought to be tasked with such a clean up are already subverted?

    So it is this smokescreen the US does not penetrate and which lets them subsequently support the Pakistani government believing their tales of upset about the ever growing radical wave. In a misguided assumption of effective counter action they pump in more and more funds to support this subverted government which does not improve the security situation yet still takes in one million after the other in aid-funds. And let's face it: this newly elected government of squabbling "democrats" will be even more powerless in the face of increased extremists' activities than the military one of Pervez Musharaf. While Pakistan is another country which should never be governed by a parliamentary democracy Afghans have to wish now for Pakistan to descend into self-created democratic chaos so that the Pakistani insurgency draws more fighters out of Afghanistan to support their opportunities across the border.

    Such are the perversions created by incapable governments supported by the West simply because of their superficial democratic credentials!

     

     

    The second issues is that there is a weak Afghan government in place which proofs day by day incapable of extending its influence and power into the provinces, it fails to protect the people against talib influence, it fails to establish a rule of law and it fails to punish the criminals under which ever banner they operate.

    The true reason is that this political system is ill-designed to produce a capable government and executive powers out of an incapable people. We should all remember that democracy "ensures that the people are not governed better than they deserve it". Parliamentary democracy is not for an LDC emerging from thirty years of conflict and mistrust in authority!!

    This country - and yes, shoot me for it - needs an authoritarian rule for quite some time - a rule which deals with threats from outside the system with measures from outside the system. A rule which brings people in line, which implements the rule and the appreciation of law, accompanied by effective sanctions. After thirty years of impunity and anarchy we have to accept that a stronger hand then elsewhere is required and also that there will be casualties - and if we don't accept this, this country will never recover. "If you play with fire, you'll get burned". And feeling the burn they must - all the enemies of this country, foreign and domestic. Because if they don't they will use their freedoms this system grants them not in support of it but against it. And a human rights-led judicial system can only punish after the criminal is proven guilty - no preventive actions are allowed. But it is exactly the latter which we lack dearly but which might not always respect the "human rights" of those who deny the same to others. Such measure are the order of the day because the forces "outside the system" are threatening to take over - they are not a minority which can be dealt with by means of civil rights leniency - they want another system, another society. And that is why they must be dealt with in an extraordinary fashion.

    Exceptional situations call for exceptional measures - and human rights and democracy can't provide those in a country like Afghanistan where the basics for such a system are not laid yet. Democracy is underpinned by education and civil awareness, while voting for illiterate people does not mean anything. What means something to them and the security of the region and ultimately the world is employment, daily security and food on their table. The form of government should be chosen with this outcome in mind, not concerned alone with the process of establishing a government and not assume in a naïve manner that a democratic process also leads to good governemance.

    Far from achieving acceptable results, this Afghan parliamentary democracy has put criminals into power who only work for their own pockets. Incapable and corrupt they suck out of their positions whatever they can. And lacking a working judicial system they get away with impunity. This is what "democracy" means in Afghanistan. Everyone has a vote, yes - and then? What do people do with it, if this vote is not turned into good governance and measures which improve their lives? This is what countries like China, Singapore, Malaysia and others recognised: freedom is not only a right but also an obligation. And if a people is not capable of handling this obligation yet, there needs to be a transition period where the people are guided in what is best for them, rather than letting them make their own decisions or rather letting them attempt to do so - them, the majority of whom are illiterate, otherwise uneducated and inexperienced and damaged by over twenty years of anarchy.

    I do realise that this is a narrow path to tread and that the Lee Kuan Yews, Mahatirs, Amanullahs and Deng Xiao Pengs are in short supply in the world. But there is an urgent need to try - Afghanistan's political system needs to be changed - not reformed - changed.

      

    So, where ARE we headed? Right now it seems as if we are headed towards another conflict in this war-battered country as neither one of the above raised points are anywhere close to being resolved

    It is not too late yet - still measures can be taken to beat back and eradicated the talibs and set right the political back drop which nurtures them both in Afghanistan and Pakistan. But such have to role in fast and furious - otherwise it is too late yet again.

     

    August 25

    Kabul Diaries

    One step forward

     
    On August 20th we had our Inaugural Meeting for the Ahmad Shah Massoud Library & Culture Centre.
    It was an exciting three hours of discussion over basic issues such as the website, land acquisition etc etc.
    This is the beginning - hopefully - of a successful project in the honor of this great man.
     
    Our website is now almost ready - http://www.massoudlibrary.org
     
    Our current goal is to raise no less than 1.3mil US$ for building, equiping and long-term financing of the Centre
     
     
    July 28

    from a tent to a 5 star hotel

    From the mountains of Afghanistan to Dubai
     

    It has been two weeks of contrast indeed, but that's what I meant it to be.

    A trip to Lake Shiwa

    First I set out with a group of friends to Badakhshan, to the entrance of the Wakhan corridor , in the north east of Afghansitan. Our destination was the mountain lake Shiwa. After fiveteen hours of driving we reached Faizabad, a small dusty mountain town with a sizable bazaar, however.

    The road from Kabul to Kishim is very good these days, but right after Kishim it's rubble again all the way to Faizabad. Now, however, USAid is building the road on this stretch and in a couple of years all this will be paved as well. For now, however, we were held up several times because of road works and explosions being condcuted to widen the road.

    We spent the night in Faizabad in a small hotel where we were also able to rent tents for our days at the lake. The hotel is basic yet comparatively clean. It doesn't have the advertised 24h electricity and no airconditioning which would have certailnly come in handy given the rather sizzling temperatures outside which much exceeded Kabul's. But we had to make due with fans only, a fridge which didn't work and only cold water in the shower. 40US$ for that were a bit steep.

    The next day we were enlightened that we had to pay 7US$ at the police station for receiving a police clearance for going to the lake. Going to the Wakhan itself would have cost 50$ per foreigner, mind you - locals go free. Interesting. My personal opinion is this: like most things attached to offical dealings in Afghansitan this is bull shit. There was a police check further up the road outside of Faizabad but they didn't even ask about this letter and thereafter we didn't need it either.

    So after wasting two hours at the police station we finally set off towards Lake Shiwa. After 1 hour past Faizabad the road soon turns into the mountains and one begins to climb. Soon one reaches the tree line and then there is nothing but rough, boulder-filled mountains. While it sounds dull, it actually isn't at all. The mountains are dramatic and the drops are steep. One shouldn't attempt this drive with anything less than a well-serviced solid 4-wheel drive.

    After some 3 hours we reached the Shiwa plateau which is comparatively green with water coming down from the surrounding mountains everywhere. It soaks the plateau and little ravines can be seen everywhere. As a result there are herds of sheep spread out all over.

    on the way back - Shiwa 4

    It took us another three hours to reach the lake but the view which presented us there certainly made the trip worthwhile.- As I got out from the care to take a photo of the lake peeking around a corner I suddenly noticed that it had turned fairly chilly and instantly regretted that I hadn't brought a winter jacket. My small cardigan wasn't going to do the job. It was quite incredible compared to the heat of Faizabad.

    Kol-e-Shiwa

    Some half an hour later we found our camping spot. Close to the entrance of the lake there were a few stone walls erected to herd animals. The "rooms" they formed made ideal spots to erect our tents and at the same time protect us from the wind which always started blowing in the afternoon. Three sleeping tents and one for cooking. We had stocked up on drinks, pasta, fruits and meat - generally easy things to cook on a bunsen burner. We had brought cooking gear, too.

    fellow travelers 3

    So after settling in we cooked our first dinner and then enjoyed it under a full moon but slightly chilly wind which made us retire to our tends fairly soon.

    The next morning I woke up at 5.30. The sun was already on the horizon and started to peek over the mountains. The lake was dead quiet, not the slightest wind - no sound of civilisation. I couldn't help but sit in my tent for several minutes just enjoying this beauty.

    sunrise at the lake

    After breakfast we took a long hike around the lake with one more spectacular views around each turn. The calm lake was like a mirror reflecting the surrounding mountains. The walkway winds up and down, sometimes touching the beach of the lake, sometimes meeting a rock cliff fifty meters above the lake.

    reflections 5

    After we returned we were ready for a nap. When we all gathered back together it was late afternoon - coffee, wine and cooking time.

    Beforet that, however, I walked down to the lake to simply dangle my feed into the water. But at a water temperature of no more than 10C the dangling didn't take long. The wind had picked up again in the afternoon and the mirror of the lake had disappeared. But with the temperatures still quite high during the day, the wind made for a welcome refreshment.

    The next day we had to head back already as one of my fellow travelers had urgent matters to attend to in Kabul. We decided to drive all the way to Kunduz the first day so we called it an early night in order to be able to get up early the next morning.

    We arrived in Kunduz at about 8pm and checked into the Kunduz Hotel. While the prices had remained the same compared to two years prior the service had decreased even further. There was a dirty towel in my room, the fan was plugged in with two lose wires and there was no key for my rooms front door. Only my bedroom could be locked, while the access to the bathroom remained open ... There was no food service and when we asked for some hot water the next morning for our instant coffee they said it would take half an hour to prepare. Not something we were prepared to wait for in return! 60US$ for that is unacceptable. Problem is - there is not much more choice in Kunduz if it comes to accomodation.

     

    Off to Dubai for some R & R

    Two days after my arrival back in Kabul I set off to Dubai for some shopping and 5 star therapy. This time I had chosen the Samaya Hotel near the Dubai Creek. A very new hotel, this place is really great - modern 5 star luxary. While a spa is missing they do have a gym and a very nicely designed - albeit small - pool on the roof.

    IMG_0781

    I don't come to Dubai for anything else but shopping, spa and nail treatment. Anyway at this time of the year it is too hot to leave a mall or hotel during the day. 45C is simply a killer.

    And then my man came to join me there one day after my arrival. We spent two more beautiful days together, just enjoying the ease, comfort and privacy of a break like this

     

    May 30

    Historic Moments seem less historic at the time

    I have  been working on a Nation Branding strategy with an expert from the US for a couple of months - and the other day we had an appointment with Ahmad Zia, the First Vice President of Afghanistan to get high-level endorsement for this project.

    Curiously I had met the VP before - three times in fact. To me it is meaningful each time despite that he doesn't even come close to his brother. And yet - it means something. Each time I can't help but wonder how it would have been if I'd be sitting in front of Amir Sahib instead, how nervous I'd be if he'd shake my hand. How I'd be "si emue sou votre regard".

    Instead there are only photographs looking down on me. Each time it brings the tears to my eyes that he is not the one exercising some power in this country.

    Still it passed like a regular meeting. Luckily we got to take photos, as the American wanted to remember this moment as much as I did. I could be a historic one indeed, if we really manage to set a re-branding process in motion.

    But then, historic moments never seem so historic at the time ...

    P1010004

    May 02

    Kabul Diaries - 02 May 08

     
    For the last two weeks we have had the most incredible weather. 20+C and clear skies. In the guesthouse have taken out our cane furniture and moved it back onto the terrace. It's a delight to sit under the fresh spring green of the trees and have a cup of tea. I have also put my Afghan bed outside in a spot where no one can see. This will be my summer resting place ...
     
    We started biking again, too. Last Friday we went to Kapisa to a most lovely spot near the Panjshir river. Near Pul-e-Sayad and yet far a way from the pick-nick crowds. We left our bikes in the care of a local farmer who had his house near by as we could not ride directly down to the river. Several children followed us and watched us curiously from a distance as we sat down to relax. Women were looking after cows, donkeies were strolling around - next to us a sheep and her little one were flogged to the ground.
    This country is the most beautiful I have been!
     
    IMG_0595IMG_0596IMG_0597